PLANO, Texas — A Collin County jury awarded $359,199.70 to a Plano woman injured in a traffic collision, sending a strong message about the responsibility of insurers to provide fair compensation. The case stemmed from an incident in October 2023 when the plaintiff was struck at the intersection of Parker and Clark by a driver who made an unprotected turn.
In a trial that saw the defense arguing that the plaintiff had insufficient evidence to support her claims, the jury decisively ruled otherwise, granting significant sums for both past physical and emotional suffering. Specifically, more than $233,000 was allocated solely for pain and mental anguish.
The jury’s verdict came in stark contrast to the insurance company’s last-minute offer, which was made just a day before the trial. This offer was deemed inadequate as it barely covered the plaintiff’s medical expenses, prompting the need for a jury trial to determine rightful compensation.
The case was heard in the 493rd Judicial District Court on June 9, 2025. Attorney Alex Ivanov, representing the plaintiff, presented a thorough case that resonated with the jury. The breakdown of the award included $116,640 for past physical pain, $116,640 for past mental anguish, and $125,919.70 for medical expenses incurred as a result of the accident.
“This verdict is about more than just financial compensation,” Ivanov stated after the decision. “It reflects the jury’s understanding of the pain and disruption our client endured. They recognized the need for accountability when someone is injured due to another’s negligence.”
The jury’s decision not only highlights this specific case but also sends a broader message to insurance companies that lowball offers will not be met without challenge. By awarding more than three times the last offer, the jury validated the plaintiff’s determination to seek a fair settlement instead of accepting an insufficient payout.
The case, ADA Nelly Cruz Medina vs. Ava Vaughn Alper, exemplifies the ongoing battle many injured individuals face against insurance companies. As the total amount awarded surpasses $400,000 when considering court costs and interest, it underscores the importance of pursuing justice in the aftermath of an accident.
As the legal battle concludes for this Plano resident, the outcome may bolster the resolve of others who find themselves in similar situations, encouraging them to stand firm against unfair settlement offers from insurers.
Disclaimer: This article was automatically written by OpenAI. The people, facts, circumstances, and story may be inaccurate, and any article can be requested to be removed, retracted, or corrected by writing an email to contact@publiclawlibrary.org.