MIAMI — A federal judge is currently weighing arguments regarding the future of an immigration detention center under construction in the Florida Everglades, a project criticized for allegedly failing to adhere to environmental regulations. Dubbed “Alligator Alcatraz,” the facility’s development has sparked controversy among environmental advocates and the Miccosukee Tribe, who argue that it poses a significant threat to vulnerable wetlands.
On Wednesday, environmental groups and the tribe urged U.S. District Judge Kathleen Williams to issue a preliminary injunction to cease construction and operations at the site. They contend that the center endangers protected wildlife habitats and undermines years of environmental restoration efforts that have cost billions of dollars.
The lawsuit, initiated in Miami against state and federal authorities, is one of two ongoing legal actions contesting the detention center, which sits on a remote airstrip owned by Miami-Dade County and was completed over a month ago. A second lawsuit from civil rights organizations alleges violations of detainees’ constitutional rights, claiming individuals are being held without formal charges and are restricted from accessing legal counsel. A hearing related to that case is scheduled for August 18.
According to the environmental advocates and the Miccosukee Tribe, federal agencies are required under a longstanding environmental law to assess the potential impact of the detention center’s construction, explore mitigation strategies, and allow public input. They argue that the involvement of state agencies in the construction does not absolve federal agencies of their responsibilities in regulating immigration and its environmental fallout.
“Building a detention center is inherently regulated by federal law,” they stated in court filings. “The State of Florida lacks the authority to enforce federal immigration statutes.”
Last week, attorneys representing the federal and state governments requested that Judge Williams dismiss or move the injunction request, suggesting that the lawsuit was improperly filed. They contended that, while the land is owned by Miami-Dade County, the litigation should be addressed in the middle district of Florida since the facility is located in Collier County.
As of now, Judge Williams has yet to make a ruling on this jurisdictional dispute. Meanwhile, the ongoing legal battles coincide with the Florida administration’s apparent plans to establish a second immigration detention facility at a National Guard training base in northern Florida, which has already seen contract awards pertaining to what is referred to in state documents as the “North Detention Facility.”
This latest development reflects ongoing tensions surrounding immigration policies and their environmental implications in the state.
For inquiries or corrections regarding this article, please send an email to contact@publiclawlibrary.org.