Hackensack, NJ — A jury in Bergen County awarded $14 million to three women who claimed they were sexually assaulted by their physician, sparking conversations about oversight and accountability within the medical field. The victims’ stories were part of an investigation that shed light on decades of misconduct by a trusted healthcare professional.
During the emotionally charged trial, attorney Kate Carballo expressed that the verdict marked a significant moment of acknowledgment and justice for the victims. “The emotional impact was palpable in the courtroom as the jury’s decision was announced,” Carballo reflected. She added that it felt as if the women finally had the opportunity to truly be heard.
The defendant, Dr. Carl Renner, was accused of inappropriate behavior and assault at his medical practice in Hasbrouck Heights, NJ. According to testimony, Renner’s actions included highly inappropriate and unauthorized physical contact. Several of his patients testified, describing unsettling encounters. Rosemarie Safarian recounted a distressing visit during which she had to physically fend off Renner as he attempted to reach under her clothing. Suzanne Brown reported that Renner forcibly kissed her and conducted a pelvic exam without explanation, despite her visit being for a respiratory complaint.
Dr. Renner had previously pled guilty to sexual assault charges and consequently surrendered his medical license as part of his plea agreement. He received a sentence of probation following his guilty plea.
Safarian and Brown, along with a third woman who requested anonymity, pursued legal action against Osler Medical Group, arguing that the practice was aware of Renner’s abusive behaviors as early as 2008 but failed to take appropriate action. The jury sided with the plaintiffs, distributing the multi-million-dollar verdict among them. Brown was awarded $4 million, Safarian and her husband also received $4 million, and the third plaintiff was awarded $6 million.
The financial awards symbolize a broader call for medical institutions to maintain diligent oversight and enforce strict codes of conduct to protect patients from similar abuses. The case highlights the integral role that such institutions play in preventing professional misconduct and ensuring safe environments for both patients and staff.
In the aftermath of the verdict, representatives from Osler Medical Group have not offered any public remarks regarding the jury’s decision.
This article was automatically generated. The facts, names, and circumstances detailed might be inaccurate. For corrections or removal requests, please reach out via email at [email protected].