MIAMI, Florida – Two prosecutors have been disqualified from a high-profile case involving the John Doe gang boss in Liberty City after allegations of prosecutorial misconduct surfaced. Miami-Dade County Circuit Judge Andrea Wolfson signed an order on Wednesday removing Miami-Dade State Attorneys Michael Von Zamft and Stephen Mitchell from the case. The decision was made based on instances of witness manipulation tactics and over 20 years of alleged misconduct by Von Zamft, as cited by Wolfson. Additionally, Wolfson pointed to Mitchell’s decision to follow Von Zamft’s lead without considering the consequences, emphasizing the importance of a fair resentencing trial for Corey Smith.
Describing Von Zamft as a highly trained lawyer with a prosecutorial philosophy of winning at all costs, Wolfson highlighted incriminating evidence that emerged during recorded jail calls. In one such call, Von Zamft discussed arranging for an inmate involved in witness elimination to be in the courtyard with potential witnesses. Wolfson identified glaring instances of misconduct in these recordings and expressed concern over potential further misconduct that may have been uncovered if the defense had sufficient time to investigate.
The disqualification of the prosecutors was not seen as a punishment for their alleged past wrongdoing, but rather, a necessary step to prevent future prejudice in Smith’s case, according to Wolfson. The decision came after an amended discovery exhibit, which suggested collaboration between the prosecutors, was presented. The exhibit had only been discussed during the hearing and revealed uncertainties regarding the State Attorney’s Office possession of essential records.
The case in question involves Corey Smith, who was convicted of four murders related to the John Doe gang’s drug distribution activities in Miami’s Liberty City neighborhood. The resentencing trial was prompted by changes in death penalty law. Smith’s initial conviction in 2004 led to life sentences for two murders and death sentences for the other two. As part of the gang’s operations, a rival’s girlfriend was fatally shot 16 times in her car, and another potential witness in the case was murdered.
Smith’s subsequent motion for collateral relief after a death sentence, which is currently pending, brought attention to the alleged prosecutorial misconduct. With the disqualification of Von Zamft and Mitchell, the case will proceed with new prosecutors who can ensure a fair trial for Smith.
This developing story sheds light on potential misconduct by prosecutors, emphasizing the importance of upholding the integrity and fairness of the legal system. The disqualification of the prosecutors in this case underscores the need for transparency and accountability in criminal proceedings, ultimately working towards justice for all parties involved.