Los Angeles, CA — A recent lawsuit has made headlines as Nick Carter, a member of the iconic pop group Backstreet Boys, faces allegations of sexual assault that purportedly led to severe health consequences for Laura Penly. Penly, who accuses Carter of infecting her with sexually transmitted diseases that could have contributed to her cervical cancer diagnosis, seeks justice in a case that echoes previous claims against the singer.
Penly claims the incidents occurred during a series of encounters with Carter in Los Angeles from December 2004 through February 2005. According to her allegations, what began as a consensual relationship took a coercive turn. She asserts that during one specific encounter at his Hollywood apartment in early 2005, despite her protests and request for him to use protection, Carter disregarded her pleas.
The repercussions of these alleged encounters were not only immediate but long-term. Penly states that shortly after her relationship with Carter, she was diagnosed with chlamydia and gonorrhea, and eventually, testing revealed the presence of cancerous cells. By mid-2005, she was battling Stage 2 cervical cancer — a condition she connects directly to the human papillomavirus (HPV), which she claims to have contracted from Carter.
The dispute extends beyond health concerns. Penly alleges that Carter coerced her into silence, leveraging his celebrity status to intimidate her and dissuade her from revealing the assault. Despite these pressures, the lawsuit indicates that Penly is now stepping forward in a push for accountability, not just from the pop star but as a call to action against a broader culture of silence surrounding sexual misconduct in the entertainment industry.
Carter, through his legal representation, has vehemently denied these allegations, characterizing them as unfounded attacks designed to tarnish his reputation. According to his attorneys, Liane K. Wakayama and Dale Hayes, Jr., there seems to be a timing strategy for airing these claims, aimed to cause maximum personal and professional damage, an assertion that raises questions about motive and truth in high-profile celebrity legal battles.
This lawsuit is not an isolated case for Carter. He has faced multiple accusations of sexual misconduct. Laura Penly is the fourth woman to bring allegations to light, following Melissa Schuman, Ashley Repp, and Shannon Ruth — the latter two of whom will have their cases heard in 2026. Despite these claims, Carter has actively sought legal remedies, going as far as countersuing some of his accusers for defamation, though not all attempts have been approved by the courts.
As Penly’s legal team, led by Gianna N. Elliot from Marsh Law Firm, articulates, these actions are seen as a means to challenge the alleged ongoing pattern of behavior by Carter and a broader systemic issue within the music industry. Elliot emphasized the courage it takes for survivors of sexual assault to come forward and the significance of their voices in instigating change.
The unfolding of this lawsuit promises to be a critical moment not just for the individuals involved but for the entertainment industry at large. It underscores a growing insistence on accountability and the complex interplay between celebrity influence and justice.
If you are seeking help or know someone affected by sexual assault, resources such as the National Sexual Assault Hotline can provide support.
Please note that this article was automatically generated. Facts, circumstances, and the story’s accuracy are not verified. Errors can be reported and content can be retracted or corrected by contacting [email protected].