CHICO, California – The community of Chico mourns the loss of former Butte County Judge, the Honorable Ann H. Rutherford. Judge Rutherford was an iconic figure in the city of Chico, leaving behind a legacy that will be remembered by many.
One Chico resident, Steve Metzger, remembered his encounter with Judge Rutherford years ago when he contested a parking ticket in her court. Metzger vividly recalled the humorous exchange that took place. In a previous case, a man had been cited for running a stoplight, but he vehemently denied doing so. Judge Rutherford had a clever way of determining the truth, asking the defendant if he had felt the sensation of coming to a full stop in the small of his back. When the man admitted he didn’t feel it, Judge Rutherford upheld the fine.
Metzger then had his turn in front of Judge Rutherford. He confidently stated that he had indeed put money in the meter. Judge Rutherford questioned him, asking how he knew that he had done so. Metzger replied, “I felt it in the small of my back.” This lighthearted response elicited laughter from everyone in the courtroom. Judge Rutherford, with a smile on her face, dismissed the case and told Metzger to “get outta here.”
The passing of Judge Rutherford leaves a void in the Chico community. Her dedication to justice and her ability to bring laughter into the courtroom will long be remembered by those who had the privilege of appearing before her. Chico residents reflect on her impact, recognizing her as a true icon of the city.
As the news spreads of Judge Rutherford’s passing, Chico residents pay their respects to an esteemed figure who left an indelible mark on the community. Her legacy will continue to inspire and influence those in the legal profession and beyond.
The loss of Judge Rutherford is deeply felt in Chico, where her presence and legacy will forever be cherished. The city remembers her with fondness and gratitude for her contributions to the local justice system and the community as a whole. The passing of Judge Rutherford marks the end of an era but leaves behind a lasting legacy that will be celebrated for years to come.