Mariah Carey’s Holiday Hit Lawsuit Likely to Be Dismissed, Judge Leans Toward Ruling in Pop Star’s Favor
Los Angeles, California — A judge in California is leaning towards dismissing the lawsuit filed against Mariah Carey over her iconic holiday song, “All I Want for Christmas Is You.” The suit, rekindled in November 2023, implicates Carey in a copyright dispute with Mississippi artist Vince Vance, credited as Andy Stone, who claims Carey’s hit mirrors his 1989 composition bearing the same title. The case, which began in 2022, saw Vance initially seek $20 million in damages. However, he dropped his lawsuit later that year only to refile it with additional details and a co-plaintiff, … Read more