AUBURN, Calif. — A jury has found former Major League Baseball pitcher Dan Serafini guilty of first-degree murder and attempted murder in a tragic case that has haunted the Spohr family for four years. The conviction stems from an ambush shooting that occurred in June 2021, resulting in the death of 70-year-old Gary Spohr and serious injury to his wife, 68-year-old Wendy Wood. Although Wendy recovered from her injuries, she later died by suicide.
The jury deliberated for two and a half days before reaching a verdict that also included special circumstances of lying in wait and using a firearm during the attack, along with a charge of first-degree burglary. However, the jury acquitted Serafini of child endangerment, a charge linked to his actions while his infant and toddler sons were present during the shooting.
Serafini is scheduled to be sentenced on August 18, where he faces the possibility of life in prison. The verdict was delivered at the Historic Auburn Courthouse, and the emotional reactions from the victims’ family were palpable. Adrienne Spohr, the youngest daughter of the victims, broke down in tears upon hearing the “guilty” announcement, expressing relief that justice had been served. She thanked the investigators for their relentless pursuit of the case and recalled the happiness of her parents before their tragic deaths.
Erin Spohr, Serafini’s wife and sister to the victims, was also visibly shaken as she left the courtroom. Many family members wore mementos honoring their deceased parents, highlighting their grief and the emotional toll of the trial. Adrienne spoke about cherished memories of mountain biking and family dinners, revealing the deep bond they shared before being shattered by violence.
The jury, made up of ten women and two men, carefully analyzed evidence, including security footage that showed a masked suspect entering the Spohr home on the day of the shooting. Juror Gracee Butrick noted that they examined the videos extensively and took meticulous notes during deliberations, emphasizing the weight of their responsibility in determining the verdict.
Deputy District Attorney Rick Miller presented compelling arguments to the jury, displaying graphic crime scene photos and establishing a timeline that connected Serafini to the crime. His closing remarks painted a vivid picture of the horrifying events, while the defense attorney, David W. Dratman, attempted to challenge the credibility of key witnesses, including Serafini’s former lover and co-defendant, Samantha Scott.
Scott testified that she had waited in the neighborhood while Serafini carried out the attack and later saw him discard gun parts and other evidence. The prosecution argued that her testimony was crucial in corroborating the timeline of events, while the defense claimed she fabricated her story as part of a plea deal.
Throughout the trial, which lasted six weeks, the courtroom was often filled with intense emotions. The complex nature of the case, including familial ties and the history between Serafini and the victims, added a layer of difficulty for jurors and those involved.
As the trial concluded, family members grappled with the need for closure while reflecting on their losses. The verdict marked a significant moment in their long journey toward justice, although the scars of their tragedy will likely remain for years to come.
The article was automatically generated by OpenAI, and the people, facts, circumstances, and content may be inaccurate. Any requests for removal, retraction, or correction can be sent to contact@publiclawlibrary.org.