Sheriffs

Alachua County Sheriff’s Office Challenges $15 Million Jury Award in Sergeant’s Discrimination Case

by

Gainesville, Fla. – A significant legal battle is unfolding in Alachua County as the Sheriff’s Office seeks to overturn a $15 million jury verdict awarded to Sergeant Kevin Davis. The verdict, handed down in early February, is now subject to motions filed this week by the Sheriff’s Office urging the court to either dismiss the jury’s decision, request a new trial, or direct a verdict in their favor. The argument presented by the Alachua County Sheriff’s Office hinges on claims that the $15 million award is “grossly disproportionate” and “outrageous,” far exceeding reasonable compensation for … Read more

$15 Million Racial Discrimination Verdict Shocks Alachua County in Case Against Sheriff’s Office

by

GAINESVILLE, Fla. – In a notable legal decision, a predominantly white jury awarded over $15 million to Kevin Davis, a sergeant with the Alachua County Sheriff’s Office, after he accused his employer of racial discrimination. This conclusion followed a weeklong trial filled with contentious debates over promotional practices within the sheriff’s office. During the proceedings, Davis was awarded $115,724 in compensation for lost wages, which economic expert David Macpherson testified he would have earned if promoted. Interestingly, the jury decided against awarding Davis $54,545 in lost pension benefits that Macpherson also estimated Davis had forfeited … Read more

Motorcyclist Engulfed in Flames Sues Osceola County Sheriff’s Office Citing Excessive Force for Minor Offenses

by

OSCEOLA COUNTY, Fla. — Following a high-speed pursuit in February 2022 that resulted in a motorcyclist being severely burned, a lawsuit has been filed against the Osceola County Sheriff’s Office. The lawsuit highlights allegations of an institutional culture that encouraged harsh and forceful law enforcement tactics even for minor violations. The incident, which received widespread attention, involved Jean Barreto, a motorcyclist who was engulfed in flames after a deputy used a taser on him while he was soaked in gasoline at a gas station. The shocking moment occurred amid deputies’ response to a report of … Read more

Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office Settles Lawsuit Over Detainee’s Suicide Amid Criticism of Jail’s Mental Health Policies

by

Jacksonville, Fla. – A legal agreement has been finalized between Jacksonville Sheriff T.K. Waters, a corrections officer, and the grieving family of Esther Joy Truax, a woman who committed suicide while detained at the Duval County Pre-trial Detention Facility. The case, settled in December, emerged after multiple suicide attempts by Truax, highlighting ongoing concerns about inmate mental health management in correctional facilities. The lawsuit accused the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office (JSO) of neglect and indifference towards Truax’s mental health, despite her documented history of suicide attempts and psychiatric struggles. Truax, who was 35 at the time … Read more