Systemic

Modoc County Domestic Violence Case Dismissed Due to Judicial Shortage, Exposing Systemic Court Delays

by

ALTURAS, Calif. — In a rare turn of events in Modoc County, a criminal case was dismissed due to a shortage of judges, illustrating the challenges smaller counties face in maintaining adequate judicial resources. On February 27, 2025, Superior Court Judge Wendy Dier was forced to dismiss a domestic violence case involving defendant Angela Totten due to the prolonged absence of a second judge in the county. The case originally stemmed from allegations against Totten including battery, battery on a spouse, and resisting arrest with penalties that could have extended up to two and half … Read more

Tulsa Officer’s Shooting Case Prompts Jury to Examine Police Training: A Deeper Look into Systemic Issues

by

Tulsa, Okla. — A legal battle concerning alleged improper training and use of force by the Tulsa Police Department is set to proceed to trial, a judge recently decreed. The focus is on a distressing incident dating back to March 2020, which was captured on body camera footage showing Tulsa Police Officer Aaron Russell firing five shots as Michael Delaney, then a suspect, maneuvered his car away from an arresting situation. Delaney who reportedly did not comply with Russell’s orders to exit his vehicle, was hit in the shoulder by gunfire. He later accepted guilt … Read more

Trial Under Scrutiny: No Black Jurors for Black Defendant in Ottawa Raises Concerns of Systemic Bias

by

Ottawa, Canada — A recent criminal trial has intensified scrutiny over racial fairness in the Canadian justice system, highlighting profound concerns about the composition of juries in cases involving racialized defendants. At the center of this judicial controversy is Honor Charley, a young Black man found guilty of second-degree murder, who faced a jury without any Black members—a detail that has ignited a fierce debate over systemic biases. Charley stood trial for the death of a white individual and the alleged attempted murder of another. The defense argued that Charley was not criminally responsible due … Read more

Utah Man Inadvertently Summoned for Jury Duty Highlights Systemic Oversight in State’s Selection Process

by

SALT LAKE CITY — The concept of jury duty, an obligation shared by many Utah residents, can evoke varied reactions: some may see it as a profound civic duty, while others view it as an unwelcome disruption. Given the range of opinions and the significant responsibilities involved, the stakes are high, extending from minor traffic infractions to serious criminal allegations. In Utah, not everyone is eligible to serve on a jury. The law exempts certain groups such as individuals coping with serious physical or mental health issues, convicted felons, and non-U.S. citizens. This eligibility criterion … Read more