AI in Court: When Automation Oversteps in Criminal Defense, Lawyers Are Left to Apologize

MELBOURNE, Australia — Advances in artificial intelligence have revolutionized numerous industries, offering tools that can simplify tasks and enhance productivity. However, a recent incident in a courtroom has raised questions about the reliability of AI in critical legal scenarios. Defense attorney Rishi Nathwani faced significant backlash after he utilized AI-generated submissions in a murder case involving a minor before the Supreme Court of Victoria. This misuse of technology became apparent when the legal documents contained fabricated quotes and even referenced fictitious legal precedents. Following the ordeal, Nathwani expressed his regret, acknowledging that he takes “full … Read more

AI Regulation Showdown: Trump’s Bill Aims for Federal Control, Sparking State vs. National Debate

CHARLOTTE, N.C. — A significant legislative initiative in Congress is igniting debates over the future of artificial intelligence regulation in the United States. As discussions unfold, differing opinions reveal a divide on how best to govern the rapidly evolving technology. Backed by former President Donald Trump, a new bill seeks to impose a sweeping federal framework for artificial intelligence oversight, effectively blocking state-level regulations. Embedded in a broader $500 million proposal, this legislation aims to eliminate existing state laws governing AI and prevent new ones from being developed. Proponents of the legislation argue that state … Read more

AI Misstep in Legal Briefing: Butler Snow Faces Judge’s Scrutiny for Fabricated Citations

On May 16 in Birmingham, Alabama, Butler Snow faced an order from a federal judge after the firm allegedly submitted court documents containing fabricated legal citations. The judge noted unsuccessful attempts to locate the claimed citations, raising significant concerns about the integrity of the firm’s legal research. Butler Snow, which represents a state official in a case involving a prison inmate who suffered multiple stab wounds, admitted to using generative artificial intelligence (AI) without proper citation verification. According to the firm, an attorney used AI tools, specifically ChatGPT, to enhance two motions, citing convenience as … Read more