Appeals

Judge Upholds $15 Million Racial Discrimination Verdict Against Alachua County Sheriff’s Office, Denies Appeals for Retrial and Reduced Damages

by

GAINESVILLE, Fla. — A local judge has refused to grant the Alachua County Sheriff’s Office a new trial or to reduce a $15 million jury award in a racial discrimination case that concluded in February. The decision came after a court hearing on Tuesday, during which Sheriff Chad Scott and his legal team argued the jury’s findings were not supported by credible evidence. Wes Gay, the attorney representing the sheriff’s office, claimed that no reasonable jury would have sided with the allegations of retaliation or discrimination, contending that the jury’s decision was influenced by emotional … Read more

San Diego County Claims Courtroom Win as Appeals Court Reduces $5 Million Award in Sheriff’s Misconduct Case

by

San Diego, California — A significant legal battle has concluded in favor of San Diego County after years of litigation surrounding a sheriff’s deputy’s excessive use of force against a handcuffed man. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals recently overturned a jury’s 2022 decision, reducing a $5 million award to Mickail Myles to a maximum of $1.5 million. The appellate court’s ruling, released on May 12, determined that there was insufficient evidence indicating lasting physical damage from the incident. The judges noted that Myles did not experience any permanent harm, apart from minor scarring … Read more

San Diego County Scores Legal Win as Appeals Court Reduces Damages in Excessive Force Case

by

San Diego, California – After years of legal battles, San Diego County has achieved a significant win in the case of Mickail Myles, a man who was assaulted by a sheriff’s deputy and bitten by a police dog while he was handcuffed. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned a previous jury ruling that awarded Myles $5 million, reducing the damages to $1.5 million, citing minimal evidence of lasting physical injury. In a ruling issued on May 12, the appellate judges noted that Myles did not suffer permanent damage from the dog bite other … Read more

San Diego County Scores Courtroom Win as Appeals Court Reduces Damages in Sheriff’s Deputy Assault Case

by

San Diego, California—After years of legal battles, San Diego County has secured a significant appellate court victory regarding a controversial case involving police misconduct. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned a $5 million jury award to Mickail Myles, who had claimed injury and emotional distress after being forcibly assaulted by a sheriff’s deputy in 2014. The appellate judges ruled that Myles’ damages should be limited to $1.5 million, stating evidence did not support the extent of his claimed lasting injuries. The decision, issued on May 12, highlighted that Myles suffered no permanent impairment … Read more